Twitter has reported a $645m (£396m) net loss having only gone public three months ago. But is this symptomatic of a greater issue, or should the shareholders not be worried?
The news that Twitter had reported a loss of $645m was taken two ways by the media and analysts: it was to be expected, and it showed that while Twitter was starting to make money, the user numbers weren’t going the same way.
This is an interesting issue, given there was concern over the fact Twitter had not made a profit in any of its financial years before filing for IPO.
Despite this, the figures didn’t lie. Twitter’s Timeline views, which has been going up solidly since Q112, fell in Q413 to levels below Q213 (151bn), from 159bn globally to 148bn. Even though the company was quick to point out these numbers represented a 26% year over year growth, it didn’t look good on the surface.
Equally worryingly, monthly active users were 241m – an increase of only 9m, which Business Insider described as “very weak progress.”
One of these newly-active users, famously, will be the new Microsoft CEO, Satya Nadella, who came out of hibernation earlier this week to tweet the following:
first commitment as CEO…i won’t wait 4 years between tweets!
— Satya Nadella (@satyanadella) February 5, 2014
Analysts present on the earnings call directed most of their questions about user growth to Dick Costolo. The Twitter CEO avoided direct answers, noting the company has a “very, very clear” roadmap to help people understand Twitter more quickly, according to WSJ notes.
Perhaps not surprisingly, shares fell by up to 12% in after-hours trading following the call.
MarketingTech is reminded of the departure of influential VP product Michael Sippey last month, who wrote in an email to employees that he’d decided it was time to move on.
The more cynical at the time questioned whether it was a case of fleeing the sinking ship – and the figures published yesterday won’t do much to dissuade the cynics.
Yet there’s still plenty for Twitter to be optimistic about.
Revenue for the company was at $243m during the fourth quarter, which was ahead of analyst estimates ($218m) and represented an increase of 116% from last year.
And analysts are still in agreement that Twitter’s mobile play is more advanced than Facebook, despite competition from WhatsApp, Line and others. Back in November Ovum analyst Eden Zoller said that social and mobile were “sweet spots” for the investor community and that Twitter’s mobile strategy was “ahead of the curve.”
As good as this is though, Twitter will need to assure analysts and shareholders that they can pick up new users more consistently and quicker than they are right now – and with Twitter’s stock falling so heavily, some traders are already convinced that won’t be the case.